Fertility owes Preservation to a Sheep

The journal Human Reproduction reported a 27-year old woman in Belgium has delivered a healthy baby boy. That would not be newsworthy if she had not been rendered sterile at 13 years old by a life-saving bone marrow transplant for sickle cell anemia.

This was neither conception with a donor egg, nor from a mature egg retrieved and frozen from her ovaries before chemotherapy. But it did involve one of her eggs, so she could become the birth mother and genetic mother. So how did it happen?

Shortly before curative treatment for sickle cell, her gynecologist harvested strips of tissue from her right ovary for frozen storage. In excellent health a decade later, her tissue was thawed and transplanted to the now sterile left ovary, as well as elsewhere. After 5 months, she had her first period, which confirmed that eggs had survived inside their follicles, and she continued having regular periods until conceiving naturally within two years. Yes, it gave her periods and fertility without any further medical help—naturally!

It’s a newsworthy case because she is first to deliver after transplanting an ovary stored from childhood. Girls undergoing sterilizing treatment are rarely offered fertility preservation, and this can be their only option. The first case of its kind was 20 years ago for a two-year-old Yorkshire infant called Harriet. We would never have suggested it except she had to undergo an operation to remove a kidney tumor, which gave us the chance to safeguard some of her ovaries “just in case.” I don’t know if she has requested the hospital to have her tissue back, but it is wise to wait until ready to start a family because we can’t predict how long a transplant will function before it fails and then plunges her back to a menopausal condition.

There have been about 40 births to women worldwide after a frozen ovary transplant, all of them healthy to my knowledge. And there is a further series of 11 women who received a fresh transplant donated by a sister at the Infertility Center of St. Louis led by my colleague, Sherman Silber, M.D. He recently reported in Reproductive BioMedicine Online that menstrual cycles have returned in every case. Two women are still cycling after 8 years, with 11 births in all. It has turned into a rather robust procedure.

While ovary transplants have been in the news for over a decade, there is no full account in public space of how they originated. The story depended on a sheep, but the idea was really a brainstorm in a blind alley. Science doesn’t always proceed linearly, and sometimes backs out of a cul-de-sac to find the main highway.

Around 25 years ago at Edinburgh University, I naively mentioned on a BBC TV science documentary that I was testing if fetal ovarian tissue can restore fertility in adult animals. This was before the era of egg donation and at a time when egg freezing was considered unsafe. Since there are more eggs in fetal ovaries than after birth, the prospects of a long functioning graft seemed high—provided the eggs were healthy for making babies. When the experiments were successful, women with premature menopause or Turner’s syndrome urged me forward, but it was an idea stillborn.

I was the target of huge opposition and not a little opprobrium from bioethicists, churches, politicians, and just about everyone else. A senior American scientist even warned me not to travel to the USA because people were saying the procedure would encourage abortion for donating tissue. Nothing was further from my mind than that horrific idea, because my research agenda was entirely pro-fertility! I had simply believed it is better to do some good with discarded tissue than no good at all, although I acknowledged there were issues about safety and consent.

The bumpy ride did, however, take me back to a new and much less controversial agenda. It was a time when cancer survival rates were starting to climb, especially for children, but sooner or later the highly toxic and aggressive treatment could make them sterile. Men had the option of semen freezing, but there was no equivalent chance of preserving fertility for children. I started to wonder if ovary banking for girls and testis banking for boys was the answer.

Roslin Institute

Frosty conceived after ovary freezing and transplantation in Scotland

We had modest hopes because freezing whole tissue is harder than single cells, but if it worked with sheep ovaries we were hopeful of the same for patients. I remember working with my colleague David Baird in a cold operating room at the experimental farm outside Edinburgh where Dolly the cloned sheep was born a few years later. We returned frozen ovarian tissue to the same ewes a month after a harvesting operation. Four to five months later the animals showed signs of graft activity, the same delay we have observed in patients. Not long afterwards, there was a pregnancy, and a little “Frosty” was born.

The Daily Telegraph September 23, 1999

The Daily Telegraph September 23, 1999

A research fellow who returned to the USA from my lab was first to transplant frozen tissue to a patient. It happened to be on my birthday in 1999 and the eve of emigration to a job at McGill University that the patient came to the UK and visited my lab. There was a huge splash in the media, perhaps because there was no other news that day!

Unfortunately for her, the graft was not successful. It had been frozen as minute fragments at an unknown center, but the attention she received encouraged others, and there was happier news for them. By 2004, the first birth was reported, and this too in Belgium.

Next Post: Naturalists, Snap that App

 

About Roger Gosden

British-born scientist specializing in human and animal reproduction & embryology. Academic career spanned from Cambridge and Edinburgh to McGill and Cornell's Weill Medical College in Manhattan where he was Professor & Research Director. Married to Lucinda Veeck Gosden, embryologist for the first successful IVF team in America, he retired early to Williamsburg, Virginia, to write and to recover from 'nature deficit disorder'
This entry was posted in Biomedical, Fertility and tagged , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.